The rules on helmet contact grew in steps. Football first banned head-first contact in 1976. High school rules then split illegal helmet contact into named fouls, added targeting in 2014, and rewrote spearing around the crown of the helmet in 2015. The National Federation of State High School Associations (NFHS) made defenseless players and targeting a point of emphasis again for 2025.
This post covers what each rule says, where the wording came from, and what it asks of coaches. Every definition below is quoted or closely paraphrased from the source named next to it.
What is spearing in football?
Spearing is one of three kinds of illegal helmet contact in high school football. The 2013 NFHS rule book, as quoted in the University of North Carolina’s annual catastrophic football injury report, defined illegal helmet contact as “an act of initiating contact with the helmet against an opponent.” It named three types:
- Butt blocking: a player starts contact with the front of the helmet against an opponent who is not a runner.
- Face tackling: a defensive player starts contact with the front of the helmet against a runner.
- Spearing: a player starts contact against any opponent with the top of the helmet.
In 2015 the NFHS rules committee changed the spearing definition. The same report quotes the new wording: “Spearing is an act by any player who initiates contact against an opponent at the shoulders or below with the crown (top portion) of his/her helmet.”
The Michigan High School Athletic Association described that change for its officials in September 2015. Its “Be the Referee” segment said a spearing foul happens “when any player hits an opponent with the crown, or top portion, of his helmet” as the first point of contact. The MHSAA said these fouls “must be called and enforced consistently throughout the season.”
What is targeting in high school football?
The NFHS added targeting to its rules in 2014 and made it a separate personal foul. The NCCSIR report quotes the 2014 definition: “an act of taking aim and initiating contact to an opponent above the shoulders with the helmet, forearm, hand, fist, elbow, or shoulder.”
Two differences from spearing matter on the field:
- Targeting covers contact above the shoulders. The 2015 spearing rule covers contact at the shoulders or below.
- Targeting can involve the helmet, forearm, hand, fist, elbow or shoulder. Spearing involves the crown of the helmet only.
The NFHS added a definition of a defenseless player in the same year. The 2025 points of emphasis repeat the idea: a defenseless player is one who, “because of physical position and focus of concentration,” is especially vulnerable to injury. The 2025 document lists passers, receivers, sliding runners, runners whose forward progress is stopped, players out of the play, and players blocked illegally from the blindside as the most common types.
What does the crown of the helmet rule say?
The crown is the top portion of the helmet. Under the 2015 NFHS wording quoted above, a player who starts contact with the crown against an opponent at the shoulders or below commits spearing. A player who takes aim and starts contact above the shoulders with the crown can commit targeting.
Enforcement has been a concern for years. In August 2013 the National Athletic Trainers’ Association (NATA) issued a statement on calling crown of the helmet violations. It asked officials, coaches and administrators to make sure penalties are assessed when violations occur. It asked that the rule apply the same way at every level, so that “the use of the top of the head is always called a penalty.” NATA also quoted athletic trainer Jon Heck: “Unfortunately, the enforcement of these rules has been uneven and infrequent.”
The same statement set out a division of work. Coaches teach the rules, players follow them, and officials enforce them.
When did football ban head-first contact?
The ban dates to 1976. The NCCSIR report says the NCAA and the NFHS made rule changes that year “to prohibit using the head as the initial contact point when blocking and tackling.” It also says the American Football Coaches Association Ethics Committee went on record against that type of blocking and tackling.
The report describes the background. An early study by Schneider counted 30 permanent cervical spinal cord injuries in high school and college football from 1959 to 1963. A later study by Torg and colleagues counted 99 such injuries from 1971 to 1975. After the 1976 rule changes, the report cites Torg’s later work showing permanent cervical cord injuries in high school and college fell from 34 cases in 1976 to 5 cases in 1984.
The same report says players still lower their heads before contact. It counts 32 players with cervical cord, spine or brain injuries due to head-first or head-down contact from 2019 through 2025. It also notes that for some events the head-first or head-down contact may have been inadvertent or accidental.
What changed for high school football in 2025?
The NFHS published its 2025 football rules changes in April 2025. None of the seven listed rule changes rewrote the spearing or targeting definitions. The changes covered equipment, electronic devices, forward fumbles out of bounds, penalty enforcement and six-player football.
The NFHS did name “Defenseless Player/Targeting” as one of three points of emphasis for 2025. The points of emphasis document, dated May 2025, makes three points coaches should know:
- Language moved. The forceful contact against a defenseless receiver language moved from Rule 2 (definitions) to Rule 9 (conduct of players). The NFHS said the old wording created confusion because it focused on the action of another player. The NFHS says the new Rule 9 wording “clearly limits the contact to a defenseless offensive or defensive receiver.”
- Avoidable contact. “Forceful contact that is avoidable should not be tolerated by coaches or game officials.”
- Responsibility. “Players must realize that the responsibility for making legal contact resides with the person initiating the contact.”
The document says coaches, game officials, players and administrators share the job of removing targeting and illegal contact against defenseless players. The NCCSIR report also notes that the NFHS added points of emphasis on targeting and defenseless players in 2022.
What do the rules ask coaches to do at practice?
The NCCSIR report includes recommendations for coaches. On skills, it says coaches should teach and drill blocking and tackling, and that players should keep their head up while tackling and running with the ball. It says contact should never start with the top or crown of the head or helmet.
On rules, it says the rules against spearing and targeting should be enforced in practice and in games. It says players should be held accountable through the rules of play, film sessions and the practice field.
Sources
- National Federation of State High School Associations. Football Points of Emphasis – 2025. 2025.
- National Federation of State High School Associations. Football Rules Changes – 2025. 2025.
- National Center for Catastrophic Sport Injury Research, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. Annual Survey of Catastrophic Football Injuries 1977–2025 (Kucera KL, Cantu RC). Listed on the NCCSIR reports page. 2026.
- Michigan High School Athletic Association. Be the Referee: Spearing. 2015.
- National Athletic Trainers’ Association. NATA Issues Official Statement on Calling Crown of the Helmet Violations. 2013.
The rules penalize leading with the head. HiTS is a training device coaches use in practice to reinforce head-up technique, with a physical cue on each rep. HiTS has no published results of its own yet. Read how it works.